The First Offer Is Where Negotiation Begins

For many business owners, selling their company is a once-in-a-lifetime event. That makes one question especially important: How do you know what your business is actually worth?

An interested buyer may come along with an attractive offer. It can be tempting to assume that offer represents fair market value, especially when the number sounds good.

But one buyer’s opinion is just that. One opinion.

We recently partnered with a leading distribution company to run a structured sale process that included both strategic and financial buyers. The result was a wide range of valuations for the exact same business, with offers ranging from 4.3x to 11.0x EBITDA.

The Same Business Can Look Very Different to Different Buyers

Nothing about the underlying company changed as those offers came in. The financials were the same. The operations were the same. The customers, employees and growth opportunities were the same.

What changed was the buyer.

A private equity firm may value a company differently than a strategic acquirer. A large independent buyer may see opportunities that a smaller regional buyer does not. Each buyer has its own strategy, existing operations and reasons for pursuing an acquisition.

That is the risk of relying on a single buyer. You may never know what someone else would have been willing to pay.

In this case, the difference between the lowest and highest offers was 6.7x EBITDA.

For a company generating $5 million of EBITDA, for example, that same spread would represent $33.5 million in value.

Competition Changes the Conversation

A good sale process is about more than finding someone willing to buy the business. It is about creating competition among qualified buyers.

When a buyer knows it is the only party at the table, there may be little reason to stretch on valuation or terms.

That changes when multiple credible buyers are involved.

By bringing several qualified buyers to the table at the same time, you create competition and give the market a chance to determine what the business is really worth.

That competition can influence more than price. It can also give an owner more leverage when evaluating deal structure, rollover equity, employment agreements, timing and other important terms.

The Goal Is Not to Create Value. It Is to Reveal It.

A competitive process does not suddenly make a business more valuable. The value was already there. The process helps reveal it.

In this example, accepting an early offer could have meant walking away without ever knowing another qualified buyer was willing to pay substantially more. The highest value did not come from simply finding a buyer. It came from creating competition among buyers.

For an owner who has spent decades building a company, that difference matters.

You only get one opportunity to sell the business you built. Before deciding what it is worth, it is worth finding out what the market is actually willing to pay.

 

About the Author

Professional Headshot of Brad Williams, one of our Managing Directors, with a smile dressed in a suit.

Bradley S. Williams

Brad has twenty years of experience in the investment banking industry. He has structured and executed a wide range of complex transactions: including corporate sales, acquisitions, mergers, joint ventures, recapitalizations, and leveraged buy-outs.

 
Previous
Previous

Financial Guidance: Before You Sell, Gift, or Transfer Your Business, Know the Tax Bill

Next
Next

The Beringer Group Mourns the Passing of our Friend and Colleague, John Fye